BLOGS WEBSITE

David Brown’s article “Is it time to reform the cornerstone of Australia’s insolvency regime?” has been published on The Conversation.

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, Research | Tagged ,
Leave a comment

Background

On 30 January 2012, the Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) came into effect. It prescribed a review within three years.  The review report, by Bruce Whittaker,  Ashursts, was recently submitted to the Attorney-General. (see www.afsa.gov.au). It is a thorough and scholarly analysis, covering almost every section of the PPSA. It can’t be done justice in a blog, but some key points can be highlighted

An Early Stocktake

Notwithstanding its 530 pages and 394 recommendations, the Review supports the continuation of the PPSA.  It concludes that the Act has yet to deliver fully on its economic promise, primarily because of its design and the lack of awareness, particularly among SMEs of its existence and impact.

The Report states the fundamentals of the PPSA are sound, but that many small improvements would assist the PPSA’s goals. Thus many of the recommendations are of the type that a particular provision be ‘retained’ or ‘not be amended’.

One noticeable feature of the PPSA is its length. It runs to 343 sections. The drafters did not just import the New Zealand provisions. There was minimal consultation with key stakeholders. Whilst the PPSA was accompanied by an Explanatory Memorandum, there are many provisions, the derivation or justification of which, is not apparent.  The reviewer suggests that a more consultative process should take place for any future amendments following from the Review.

(more…)

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, Research | Tagged , , ,
Leave a comment

As the clock strikes midnight tonight (Eastern time), the ‘transitional period’ of 24 months grace for PPS registrations will expire. There have been 7.7 million registrations as at end of 2013, but the feeling is that, now that the crunch time has arrived, many suppliers, lessors, consignors and others, particularly smaller businesses and artisans, will have ‘missed the boat’ in relation to interests which amount to PPSA security interests and need protection. In terms of judicial activity, to date it has been sparse, with the Maiden Civil case [2013] NSWSC 852 (see note in (2013) 13 Ins LB 278 (D. Brown)) representing the only case so far with any in-depth treatment of issues under the Act itself, with other judgments being confined largely to registration time extensions under the Corporations Act.
Now that the transitional period has expired, there is an expectation of more dispute and litigation, at least in cases where it is worth the candle to argue about priorities and effectiveness of registration. We should see some more detailed guidance emerging, as has happened in New Zealand, particularly in the insolvency context which seems to be the front line for PPSA disputes. Secondly, the fuzzy arguments about transitional security interests will become history; a search of the register should from now on disclose a more accurate picture of the whole story in relation to the debtor’s security interests (or at least those which have been registered, and with clearer and more drastic consequences if they have not).
Lastly, whilst today marks one key milestone, the next is the date for completion of the Attorney-General’s review of the PPSA. Under the Act, this review must be completed by this time next year. It does seem a little soon to be reviewing the operation of the Act, and whilst the Government will receive submissions containing gripes (some justified, but many arising, in our view, through misunderstanding of the intent and limitations of the Act and Register), the full tilt of the legislation will only be felt after today’s date, so one hopes that if the review has to be completed by this time next year, at least it won’t be the final opportunity to amend the legislation in light of issues that arise thereafter. It would be a shame if the review was to be the last word for many years, given that many small businesses still haven’t woken up to the existence and impact of the legislation. Nevertheless, with millions of registrations and an efficient, informative and responsive AFSA operation, achievements to date in what, we must remind ourselves, is the only National online register of its kind anywhere in the world, have been an impressive base from which to build.

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, News, Research | Tagged , , , , ,
Leave a comment

Read my story in The Conversation at   http://theconversation.com/kodaks-survival-not-a-black-and-white-issue-17825

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, News, Research | Tagged , , , , , , ,
Leave a comment

It was 20 years ago in June since Voluntary Administration was introduced in Australia. To mark the occasion, we’ve gathered together an domestic and international expert panel to evaluate the VA, and benchmark it against UK and Canadian rescue procedures. Friday 26 July 2013, 9-12.15, Henry Basten Room, Mitchell Building, North Terrace, University of Adelaide […]

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, News, Research | Tagged , , , , ,
Leave a comment

This week marked the first birthday of the operational commencement of the PPSA and its Register. To celebrate, BILS is organising a major two-day conference, Personal Property Security Law: Local and Global Perspectives, on 20-21 February 2013 at the Adelaide Festival Centre. For online registration and programme details: http://www.law.adelaide.edu.au/events/ppsa  Leading international and national experts will […]

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, News, Research | Tagged , , , , , , , , , ,
Leave a comment

Personal Property Security Law: Local and Global Perspectives, 20-21 February 2013, Adelaide Festival Centre Keynote address: Sir Roy Goode CBE QC  For full details of programme, information and online registration, click here:  http://law.adelaide.edu.au/events/ppsa/  The PPSA came into force on 30 January 2012, the most significant commercial law development in Australia for decades. Just over one year […]

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, Research | Tagged , , , , ,
Leave a comment

Unfair preferences feature in many insolvencies. Whilst liquidators will often have difficulty in recovering them, creditors may have difficulty in defending them. Shortly before liquidation a company is likely to pay some debts and the task of the law is to determine which of these payments can be set aside as a preference. This seminar […]

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, News, Research | Tagged , , , , , , ,
Leave a comment

BILS@ Adelaide Law School  announces conference on PPSA to take place at the Adelaide Festival Centre just over one year after the Australian PPSA’s commencement of operation. International and national experts will attend. For further details and registration page, please check http://law.adelaide.edu.au/events/ppsa/

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, News, Research | Tagged , , , , , , , ,
Leave a comment

In this blog we reproduce (with kind permission) a blog by Chris Laughton, of Mercer & Hole in the UK, who is immediate past President of INSOL Europe, see www.mercerhole.co.uk Some of the issues in this blog, though tuned to the UK/European  framework and context, seemed to us to resonate here in Australia. In particular […]

Posted in Commerce, Innovation & Technology, Research | Tagged , , , , ,
Leave a comment